Holywater: An Old Soul on Conti Street

Co-owner Alex Pincus behind the stick at his new restaurant Holywater, photo by Ellis Anderson


November 2026

Two brothers return to their French Quarter roots, bringing a fresh vision – and a familiar sense of belonging – to the neighborhood.

– by Kim Ranjbar


Walking up to Holywater – with its whale-of-a-sign swinging from the gallery’s rafters and the din of revelers flowing out the front door – you feel as if you’re about to step into the bar that was your granddad’s favorite watering hole.  


the whale of a sign on Conti Street, photo by Ellis Anderson



But Holywater only opened two months ago, 

This column is underwritten in part by Matthew Peck Gallery

If it seems the oyster house and bar have been there for decades, that’s because owners Alex and Miles Pincus are New Orleans locals – brothers who spent much of their youth gadding about in the French Quarter.

“I’ve had such a long-running experience in the Quarter. Holywater is not a particular place so much as a combination of moments and various places,” says co-owner Alex Pincus.

“I mean, the first bar I went to was Johnny White’s [a classic French Quarter bar that was half a century old before it closed in 2020] and I remember the feeling of that old, layered space.”

Alex and Miles Pincus themselves were living fixtures of the upper French Quarter. Alex spent the first three years of his life a few blocks away in a second-floor apartment of LaBranche Building – easily the most photographed structure in the French Quarter – before the family moved out to the lakefront a few years later. 


Family photos of Anne Pincus with Alex in the French Quarter

Miles and Alex Pincus at the Royal Orleans company party in the early 80’s with New Orleans mayor Ernest Nathan "Dutch" Morial.

The Pincus Brothers

The boys’ father, Ronald Pincus, managed the Royal Orleans Hotel (now the Omni Royal Orleans) for two decades before moving to the Hotel Monteleone, where he served as COO for more than twenty years.

Their mother, Anne Pincus, founded the New Orleans Famous Praline Company nearby on Royal Street – she’s also Chairman Emeritus of the Pirate’s Alley Faulkner Society. And Alex’s older brother Matthew spent 15 years working out of the NOPD’s Eighth District Station, just a few doors down from Holywater.

“Pretty much my entire life has just been hovering around this little corner of the French Quarter,” explains Alex.

When they weren’t roaming the neighborhood, the brothers could be found on or near the water, building boat kits and taking them out onto Lake Pontchartrain or to Bayou St. John.

“We started messing around with canoes, kayaks and sailboats and it became a huge part of our lives. Now we’re restoring 150-foot historic ships,” says Alex. 

“I’m personally much happier when I’m on a boat out on the water, and we just tried to build our lives around that.”

Because of their love of sailing, the brothers founded Crew in 2014, a New York-based hospitality group dedicated to restoring historic ships and buildings and creating unique waterfront experiences. Their flagship restaurant, Grand Banks, launched that same year.  It’s a seasonal oyster bar and restaurant located aboard the Sherman Zwicker, a 1942 wooden fishing schooner docked at Pier 25 in Tribeca. 

“I was an architect, and my brother and I had also started a sailing company that we ended up selling.  We were trying to figure out what to do with ourselves,” says Alex. 

“We had an idea to open a bar in New York, and the deeper we got into it, the more we learned about the waterfront and how there was a whole world of floating oyster saloons back in the 1800s.” 

In a little over a decade of fair winds and following seas, Crew has grown into a restaurant group with nine different locations – two of which are right here in their hometown.  Seaworthy, their Warehouse District restaurant, is now celebrating its 10th anniversary. Holywater on Conti is the Vieux Carré version of its Lower Manhattan namesake. 


The upstairs dining room at Holy Water, photo by Ellis Anderson


 
622 Conti Street 

“I had not been planning to do another restaurant in New Orleans,” says Alex, “But I was just so taken with the space that I effectively didn’t have a choice.”

Holywater is housed in an 1830s, three-story building designed by French architect Jacques Nicolas Bussière de Pouilly. Pouilly was well-known for his work on funerary architecture – the man responsible for many of the tombs and mausoleums in our Parisian-inspired above-ground cemeteries –  and still-standing structures such as the St. Augustine Church in Tremé. 

Past lives of the Conti Street structure include the restaurant supply store GA Lotz, and popular local bar Melius, but Alex says the building began life as a maritime chandlery, selling supplies to ship captains working on the Mississippi River. 


622 Conti Street in 1939, Louisiana State Museum


Melius Bar, 1976, Vieux Carré Virtual Library


Looking out on Conti Street from Holywater’s balcony, photo by Ellis Anderson


During the two-year renovation, Alex – an award-winning architect in his own right who led New York City–based architecture firm Bureau V – worked with a handful of architects to manage different components of the design, from John Williams of Williams Architects to designers at firm Studio BKA.     

While he doesn’t see himself as an interior designer, Alex handled all of the finishes and furnishings, from the raucous cocktail and oyster bar where every square inch of wall space is covered in photographs, art and maritime paraphernalia, to the intimate bordello-esque, tin-ceilinged lounge tucked behind the upstairs dining room.





“I manage all of the design thinking throughout our company and all of the art specifications from top to bottom, so every single material, color and shape went through me – for better or worse,” laughs Alex. “It’s a real labor of love.”   

“I’ve always enjoyed the sort of high/low experience you can have in New Orleans, where things can be very proper one moment and then sort of devolve into high-spirited debauchery the next,” explains Alex.  “I want you to be able to experience both and go from one to the other - to feel like you’re moving through spaces that speak to the experience of being in New Orleans.” 


Holywater’s wine cellar, photo by Ellis Anderson


Holywater’s wine cellar, photo by Ellis Anderson


Most of the memorabilia, especially on the ground floor, are photographs and pieces gifted to the Pincus brothers from friends and co-workers involved in the restaurant. A few pieces are from local artist – and Alex’s high school mentor – Robert Tannen. 

“If you go to his house, it’s actually what Holywater [the ground floor] looks like. Every surface is covered with layers and layers and layers of incredible art that he has made or collected in his life.” 

Much of the furniture at the restaurant also came in the form of gifts from friends and family, including his parents’ kitchen table which has a special front window spot in the oyster bar –  a piece his mom still gives him grief about. 

“It’s a place full of things that are meaningful to us, given to us by people we care about.”  

Chef Alex Harrell

At its heart, Holywater is an oyster bar with a cocktail menu curated by James Beard award-winning bartender, bar group owner and author Neil Bodenheimer. On any given day, guests can slurp their way through a rotating menu of oysters from both coasts and the Gulf; Brightside oysters from Grand Isle to Sailor Baby oysters, grown in collaboration with Crew by West Robins Oyster Co. in South Hampton, NY.



“I love oysters. I first started getting into oysters when I started getting them for free,” laughs Alex. “The Monteleone had an oyster bar made from Mr. Monteleone’s old fishing boat. We used to go there and have lunch and get oysters.”   

Upstairs, Holywater takes on a more formal feel, becoming a wharfside seafood restaurant, replete with a local ambiance and esteemed chef Alex Harrell at the helm.

 “I have a lot of friends who are restaurateurs and chefs in New Orleans and I started asking around who they thought would be a good fit,” explains Pincus. “Every single person said to talk to Alex Harrell. I thought ‘how good could this guy be?’”


Executive Chef Alex Harrell at Holywater


An Alabama-native, Harrell has long been in the local restaurant scene, from training with Susan Spicer at Bayona and opening LeBlanc + Smith’s Chartres Street restaurant Sylvain, to heading his own French Quarter restaurant, Angeline, for several years.

After a lot of friendly encouragement, Harrel was lured away from his most recent gig as executive at the Southern Hotel, and its restaurant The Gloriette, in Covington. 

Although Holywater’s New Orleans menu includes some of the “greatest hits” from the New York location, several dishes are all Harrell – such as the swoon-worthy Swordfish Schnitzel with an anise-hinted celery root remoulade and lemon beurre monte.  And the crispy, cornmeal-coated, Gulf fish served with buttery grits and braised collard greens.


Caviar Tater Tots with crème fraîche and pickled red onion at Holywater, photo by Ellis Anderson

Pickled veggie plate at Holywater


Filé croquettes, think gumbo arancini, at Holywater


Caesar Salad in a Parmesan flurry at Holywater



Swordfish Schnitzel at Holywater, photo by Kim Ranjbar


Harrell says working with the brothers has been “nothing but positive.  They’re always asking for my input and they’re very easy to work with and very supportive,” 

“I loved being on the Northshore, but I really missed the connection I have with the New Orleans restaurant community,” admits Harrell. “The opening of Holywater had the same kind of feel for me as opening Sylvain. Just the familiarity of the neighborhood, the businesses, and the flow. It’s nice to be back in the neighborhood.”

The Pincus brothers feel the same way.  Before Holywater opened, the Pincus brothers’ friends, family and team members gathered to celebrate the very special homecoming and family friend Reverend Maryetta M. Anshutz blessed the bar. 

“Holywater ties together all of the feelings that we have about New Orleans,” says Alex. [The name] is a play on words - it has to do with spirits, with New Orleans being a city of water – sometimes underwater, but definitely defined by water.” 

“Plus it just sounds like a place where it’d be fun to have a drink.”


Photo by Ellis Anderson


Alex Pincus, photo by Ellis Anderson




Kim Ranjbar

Though she was born in the San Francisco Bay Area, Kim Ranjbar felt New Orleans calling her home as soon as she hit puberty. A graduate of granola U (a.k.a. Sonoma State University), Kim took her passion for the written word and dragged it over 2000 miles to flourish in the city she loves. After more than twenty years as a transplant — surviving hurricanes, levee failures, oil spills, boil water advisories and hipster invasions — Kim hopes to eventually earn the status of local and be welcomed into the fold. Read more of her work on her website sucktheheads.com.

Previous
Previous

Explore Our Archives

Next
Next

Jerome “Big Duck” Smith, 1939 - 1926